Skip to content

Brooklyn recap

By Colm Toibin

Every recap below is hidden until you open it. Each one is safe to read once you have finished the chapter it names.

In short (whole book)

With few prospects in 1950s Enniscorthy, Eilis Lacey accepts a job arranged by Father Flood in Brooklyn. She endures a difficult crossing, severe homesickness, and work at a department store, then gradually builds a life through night classes and her relationship with Tony Fiorello, an Italian American plumber. When her sister Rose dies suddenly, Eilis decides to visit her widowed mother in Ireland. Tony fears she will not return and persuades her to marry him secretly before she sails. At home, Eilis slips into Rose's office role and is courted by Jim Farrell, making an Irish future seem newly possible. She conceals her marriage and postpones leaving until Miss Kelly shows that the secret has traveled from Brooklyn. Eilis tells her mother the truth and returns to America, leaving Jim behind and choosing the life and husband awaiting her in Brooklyn.

Story so far - through chapter 1 (this book)

Eilis Lacey lives in Enniscorthy with her widowed mother and her older sister Rose. Although Eilis has studied bookkeeping, the weak local economy offers her no regular position, and she reluctantly accepts Sunday hours under the contemptuous shopkeeper Miss Kelly. Rose, who has a steady office job and supports the household, discusses Eilis's future with Father Flood, an Irish priest visiting from Brooklyn. He can arrange work in a New York department store and lodging in an Irish boarding house. Eilis realizes that Rose and their mother have already accepted emigration as the sensible course. She agrees without feeling that the decision is fully her own. After farewells to her family and friends, she leaves Ireland for the first time, carrying their hopes and the knowledge that the move may be permanent.

Story so far - through chapter 2 (this book)

On the Atlantic crossing Eilis shares a cabin with Georgina, an experienced traveler who protects her from inconsiderate neighbors and helps her through violent seasickness. Georgina also prepares her for immigration procedures and the practical demands of arrival. In Brooklyn, Eilis moves into Mrs. Kehoe's all-female boarding house and begins selling goods at Bartocci's department store under Miss Fortini. The unfamiliar routines, crowded streets, formal boarding-house dinners, and distance from home leave her intensely homesick. Her letters conceal much of her misery from Rose and her mother. When Father Flood recognizes how badly she is struggling, he enrolls her in evening bookkeeping classes, giving her work toward a future rather than merely an empty sequence of days. The new purpose begins to steady her.

Story so far - through chapter 3 (this book)

Eilis becomes more competent at Bartocci's and continues her night studies. At a parish dance she meets Tony Fiorello, an Italian American plumber who attends because he hopes to meet an Irish girl. Tony courts her openly, walking her home, taking her to films and baseball, and introducing her to his close family. His confidence about their future moves faster than Eilis's cautious feelings, but she comes to love him and finds that Brooklyn now contains a life she chose rather than only one arranged for her. She passes her examinations, widening her prospects beyond the sales counter. The stability collapses when a message arrives that Rose has died suddenly in Ireland. Eilis is overwhelmed by grief and by the thought of her mother alone at home, while the ocean once again separates her from the family that needs her.

Story so far - through chapter 4 (this book)

After Rose's death, Eilis speaks to her mother by telephone and resolves to return to Enniscorthy for an extended visit. Tony fears that family duty and the familiarity of home will keep her in Ireland. Before she leaves, he asks her to marry him. Eilis hesitates over the haste and secrecy, but the couple complete a civil marriage without telling her family, intending to hold a public ceremony later. She promises Tony she will return to Brooklyn. The marriage turns the voyage from a simple visit into a test of obligations she has not reconciled: she is legally tied to Tony and the American future they have discussed, yet she feels responsible for the mother whose life has been emptied by Rose's death. She sails for Ireland while keeping the marriage secret from those awaiting her there.

Story so far - through chapter 5 (this book)

In Enniscorthy, Eilis finds that America has changed both her appearance and her place in the town. She supports her grieving mother, attends her friend Nancy's wedding celebrations, and is offered temporary bookkeeping work that resembles the position Rose held. Jim Farrell, whom she once regarded as distant, begins seeking her company and treats her as a serious prospect for marriage. Eilis enjoys his attention and sees the outline of a comfortable Irish life that was unavailable before she emigrated. She delays her booked return, gives vague answers to Tony's letters, and tells neither Jim nor her mother that Tony is already her husband. Her silence allows two incompatible futures to remain open. As her connection with Jim deepens, the promise she made in Brooklyn becomes easier to avoid but no less binding.

Story so far - through chapter 6 (this book)

Miss Kelly summons Eilis and reveals that news of her Brooklyn marriage has reached Enniscorthy through family connections. The conversation makes clear that the secret will not remain private and that Eilis can no longer continue accepting Jim's courtship as though she were free. She returns home and tells her mother that she married Tony before crossing the Atlantic and must leave for New York immediately. Her mother responds with controlled practicality rather than the emotional reckoning Eilis expected, helping arrange the departure while recognizing that her daughter now belongs to a life elsewhere. Eilis leaves without meeting Jim again or explaining herself to him directly. She begins the journey back to Brooklyn, imagining how her disappearance will look from Enniscorthy. Tony remains in America awaiting her; the novel ends before their reunion, with Eilis committed to returning to her husband and the home she made across the ocean.

How does it end? (ending)

Back in Enniscorthy, Eilis temporarily occupies the place Rose left behind: she helps her mother, takes office work that uses her bookkeeping training, and is welcomed into a social circle that once seemed closed to her. Jim Farrell courts her, and she delays telling either him or her mother that she married Tony before leaving New York. Miss Kelly eventually reveals that news of the marriage has reached Ireland through her connection to Brooklyn. Faced with public exposure and the consequences of her silence, Eilis finally tells her mother that she is married and must return. Her mother receives the news without a confrontation and helps her prepare to leave. Eilis departs Ireland for Brooklyn, ending her possible future with Jim without meeting him again. The novel closes during her journey, with Tony still across the Atlantic and Eilis committed by both marriage and choice to the American life she had nearly abandoned.

More about this book

Community-written - CC BY-SA 3.0. Improve this recap