Skip to content

The Hating Game recap

By Sally Thorne

Every recap below is hidden until you open it. Each one is safe to read once you have finished the chapter it names.

In short (whole book)

Lucy Hutton and Joshua Templeman are executive assistants to rival co-chief executives after two publishing companies merge. Seated opposite each other, they turn mutual scrutiny into a daily series of hostile games. When both compete for a new management role, Lucy believes victory is necessary because neither could bear reporting to the other. An impulsive kiss, a team-building retreat, and Joshua's care when Lucy becomes ill expose an attraction neither can fit into the rivalry. Lucy accompanies him to his brother's wedding, learns about the family comparisons and romantic betrayal behind his reserve, defends him, and becomes his lover. Back at work she discovers Joshua has withdrawn from the promotion process and plans another career path. He confesses that he has loved her for a long time. Lucy wins the advancement without defeating him, and they finally turn their intense attention to each other into an honest relationship.

Story so far - through chapter 5 (this book)

After the merger of Gamin Publishing and Bexley Books, executive assistants Lucy Hutton and Joshua Templeman share an office while serving the company's two co-chief executives. Lucy identifies with Gamin's warm, creative culture; Joshua represents Bexley's formal, numbers-driven side. They watch each other constantly and invent competitive routines from staring contests to calculated politeness, each insisting that the attention is hatred. A newly proposed chief operating officer position raises the stakes because both want it, and whoever loses may have to report to the winner. Lucy treats the contest as a test of her professional worth and vows to resign rather than work beneath Joshua.

Story so far - through chapter 10 (this book)

Lucy and Joshua's hostility becomes harder to distinguish from attraction. A charged confrontation leads to a kiss that surprises Lucy with its intensity and leaves her reconsidering years of assumptions. She tries to direct her attention toward Danny Fletcher, a friendly designer who offers a less complicated romantic possibility, but Joshua reacts in ways that suggest jealousy. Their competition for promotion continues, and neither is willing to be the first to admit vulnerability. The games remain an indirect language through which they reveal how closely each has studied the other.

Story so far - through chapter 15 (this book)

At a company paintball retreat, the physical strain and the pair's constant rivalry push Lucy past her limits. She becomes seriously ill, and Joshua abandons the contest to care for her, taking her to a doctor and watching over her. In his apartment she sees signs of a private life unlike the cold, controlled image he presents at work. His attentiveness cannot easily be explained as professional duty or dislike. Once she recovers, their teasing resumes, but Lucy now knows that Joshua notices her needs and will protect her when it matters. Her prospective date with Danny and the looming promotion keep both of them from dealing plainly with what has changed.

Story so far - through chapter 20 (this book)

Joshua asks Lucy to accompany him to his brother Patrick's wedding, and she agrees to pose as his partner. Away from the office, she learns that Patrick is the favored son and that the bride, Mindy, once had a relationship with Joshua before choosing his brother. The visit reveals the family comparisons beneath Joshua's defensiveness. Lucy's role begins as a performance, but her loyalty to him is genuine. She sees that his apparent invulnerability has protected a longstanding hurt, while Joshua's family quickly notices the closeness the pair still struggle to name.

Story so far - through chapter 24 (this book)

At the wedding, Joshua's father belittles his career and compares him unfavorably with Patrick. Lucy openly defends Joshua, voicing the respect and admiration she has concealed beneath their games. The confrontation brings them closer, and the false relationship they presented to his family becomes real. Lucy and Joshua sleep together and admit enough of their attraction to make a return to simple office hostility impossible. Yet Lucy still believes they are competing for one promotion and fears that professional victory for either of them will destroy what has begun. Joshua remains reluctant to explain his plans, so the central misunderstanding survives their new intimacy.

Story so far - through chapter 28 (this book)

Back at work, Lucy prepares for the promotion interview while trying to understand Joshua's withdrawal. She learns that he has removed himself from contention and intends to leave for a different professional opportunity, meaning he never planned to become her boss. The competition that seemed to bar a relationship dissolves without requiring Lucy to sacrifice her ambition. Joshua reveals that his careful observation of her, including details she took as ammunition in their games, came from love rather than hatred. Lucy recognizes that her own fixation has also been attraction expressed through rivalry. She advances professionally, and they choose an honest romantic relationship, ending the contest that allowed both to hide their feelings.

How does it end? (ending)

Lucy and Joshua return from Patrick and Mindy's wedding with their attraction acknowledged, but their competition for the new management job still appears to make a lasting relationship impossible. As the interviews approach, Lucy learns that Joshua has withdrawn from consideration. His apparent ambition was never a plan to become her superior; he intends to leave and pursue a different professional future, allowing her to take the promotion on her own merits. The details she once read as hostility are finally reinterpreted as evidence of sustained attention and affection. Joshua admits that he has loved her for a long time, and Lucy accepts that her obsession with him was never simple hatred. They begin a relationship after replacing their adversarial office games with direct honesty. Lucy's career advances, while Joshua chooses work outside the contest that had trapped them together.

More about this book

Community-written - CC BY-SA 3.0. Improve this recap